What You Need to Know about Performance-Enhancing Supplements
By Jane Park
Do
you want your body to be "ultra-lean, ripped, and strong?" Do
you want your "skin to appear paper-thin while your muscles look
incredibly hard and vascular?" These are questions that nutritional
supplement manufacturers ask in order to sell the latest bodybuilding
and performance-enhancing product. Athletes of all ages who are seeking
a competitive edge may give in to untruthful advertising strategies. As
a result, they can endanger their own health while trying to improve their
physique.
There
are thousands of nutritional and dietary supplements being sold today,
ranging from vitamins, minerals, herbs, and amino acids. However, the
Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the government agency that regulates
food, drugs, and medical devices, does not test the safety or effectiveness
of supplements before they are placed on the market. Consequently, when
you buy a nutritional supplement, you may not get what you pay for.
"Labeling
with dietary supplements is lightly and loosely regulated," said
David Schardt, associate nutritionist at the Center for Science in the
Public Interest, a consumer watchdog group. "The labels are often
misleading, incomplete and not a good guide to using the product."
Larry Bowers, professor and director of the athletic drug testing and
toxicology laboratory at the Sports Medicine Drug Identification Laboratory
at Indiana University Medical Center, reported that his lab tested a bottle
of herbal "medicine" and made an unexpected discovery. "The outside
of the bottle said it was a Chinese herbal medicine, but it turned out
to be pure steroid. Since there is no regulatory oversight of these compounds
and there’s no one checking to see what’s in it, it could be anything."
Not
only is there a risk that the label is incorrect, but most nutritional
supplements have not been tested for safety. Are there harmful long-term
side effects? No one knows for sure. It takes ten to twenty years to do
a complete study to determine if a product has long-term side effects.
Many popular supplements have only emerged within the last few years.
In truth, there are few conclusive studies that have been done on even
the short-term side effects of many new products.
Here
are some facts about nutritional supplements that have become popular
among athletes and body builders:
Creatine
-
Creatine
is a substance that is produced in the human body by the liver and
kidneys. It is present in muscle, nerve, and sperm cells.
-
Supplement
manufacturers claim that by increasing creatine in the diet, phosphocreatine
concentration increases in muscle; thus, high energy phosphate is
more readily available for energy production during muscle contraction.
-
A
few short-term studies have been conducted (none were conducted for
longer than three months) on creatine and its effects. However, the
studies have resulted in different outcomes. There is no consensus
that creatine use translates into increased performance, strength,
muscular endurance, or lean body mass.
-
Creatine
is obtained by eating meat. Dosages recommended by supplement manufacturers
are far greater than one would be able to ingest via food, but no
one knows how much is too much.
-
One
short-term side effect of creatine supplementation that has been consistently
observed is weight gain. It is believed that this gain is due to an
increase in total body water.
-
The long-term risks from using creatine supplements have never been studied.
Androstenedione [and related compounds including Androstenediol, Norandrostenedione, and Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA)]
-
Androstenedione,
androstenediol, and norandrostenedione are steroid precursors. Theoretically,
they could increase testosterone production. DHEA is a hormone that
the body converts to androstenedione.
-
Androstenedione
was made popular when baseball player Mark McGuire admitted to using
the supplement in 1998.
-
One
eight-week study evaluated androstenedione supplementation in healthy
men aged 19-29 years, but no changes in testosterone level, muscle
size, strength, or overall body composition were observed.
-
No
long-term studies have been conducted. However, if these substances
can increase testosterone production (as the manufacturers claim),
they would most likely cause the same adverse effects associated with
anabolic steroids (such as hypertension, liver tumors, psychosis,
aggression, etc.).
-
DHEA
is banned by the International Olympic Committee (IOC). Androstenedione,
androstenediol, and norandrostenedione are also banned by the IOC,
the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), and the National
Football League (NFL).
Caffeine and Ephedrine Combination
-
This
combination is often found in "energizing" and diet supplements,
and manufacturers claim it increases energy, decreases appetite, and
increases metabolism without exercise.
-
There
are many known side effects of taking the herbal product ephedrine
(also known as ephedra, ma huang, epitonin, or sida cordifolia). Some
of the side effects include insomnia, anxiety, irritability, nervousness,
rapid heart rate, nerve damage, psychosis, stroke, memory loss, and
drastic increase in blood pressure. The potential for abuse is high;
ephedrine-containing products are considered addictive.
-
When
ephedrine is coupled with caffeine, which is a stimulant, the severity
and frequency of adverse side effects increase.
-
At
least 17 deaths have been linked to products that combine caffeine
and ephedrine.
Everyday new products are advertised, making promises that are often too good
to be true. Consumers who desperately want to look and feel better
are the unsuspecting guinea pigs for these untested products. Before
you decide to buy nutritional supplements, it is important to gather
objective information (not from the manufacturers), and to consult
with your doctor or another health professional.
The FDA Guide to Dietary Supplements: http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms/fdsupp.html
The FDA has recommended tips and warnings for consumers buying nutritional
supplements and medications on the Internet:
-
Don’t
buy from sites that offer to prescribe a prescription drug for the
first time without a physical exam, sell a prescription drug without
a prescription, or sell drugs not approved by FDA.
-
Don’t
do business with sites that don’t provide access to a registered pharmacist
to answer questions.
-
Avoid
sites that do not identify with whom you are dealing and do not provide
a U.S. address and phone number to contact if there is a problem.
-
Don’t
purchase from foreign websites at this time. It will most likely be
illegal to import the drugs bought from these sites. The risks are
greater, and there is very little the U.S. government can do if you
get ripped off.
-
Beware
of sites that advertise a "new cure" for a serious disorder
or a quick cure-all for a wide range of ailments.
-
Be
careful of sites that use impressive-sounding terminology to disguise
a lack of good science or those that claim the government, the medical
profession, or research scientists have conspired to suppress the
product.
-
Steer
clear of sites that include undocumented case histories claiming "amazing"
results.
-
"Naturally
occurring" and "organic" claims on a label do not mean
the product is safe.
-
Talk
to your healthcare professional before using any medications for the
first time.
-
Check
with the National Association of Boards of Pharmacy [www.nabp.net,
(847) 698-6227] to determine whether a website is a licensed pharmacy
in good standing.
Consumers who suspect that a site is illegal can report it to the
FDA: http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms/ds-rept.html
To separate fact from fiction on other Internet Health info, click
here.
|