| |
|
| SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER
(Editorial) |
January 12, 2007 |
Women's Health: A red-flag warning
We've never had much faith in the FDA, but its approval of silicone
gel-filled breast implants marks an all-time low for the agency.
Restricted since 1992, the implants were deemed unsafe because
of the health risks associated with them, such as cancer. The
FDA currently recommends that only women over the age of 22 get
the implants. It also asks the makers of the implants (which can
rupture during a mammogram), Allergan Corp. and Mentor Corp.,
to carry out a 10-year, 80,000-patient study in order to "fully
answer important questions" regarding the products safety. Say
what? The approval of the implants is completely backasswards.
Clearly, (lobbying) money talks, and in this case, it jiggles
for a few years before it hardens and leaks toxins into your lymph
nodes, joints, uterus and liver.
Roughly 5 percent of U.S. women likely will get the implants in
the next decade.
We spoke to two experts on the matter: Diana Zuckerman, president of the National Research Center for Women and Families at the University of Pennsylvania Center for Bioethics, and Susan Wood, a research professor at George Washington University's School of Public Health. The two scientists want you to know a few things:
-
Post-approval studies are common, but the sheer scope
of this one should be a red flag. Also, neither the age of
breast-implant recipients nor the collection of data by the
two companies can be enforced.
-
Although you can pay for the implants in installments, you
can't do so for their removal -- and they will need to be
removed or replaced. Health insurance seldom covers those
additional surgeries.
-
You'll need to get pricey MRIs regularly. And no, your insurance
probably won't cover them.
- By no means should you take the FDA's approval of the implants to mean that they're safe. For example, their effect on breast milk, says Zuckerman, has "never, ever, ever been tested" by the FDA.
How's that for looking after public safety?
© 1998-2007 Seattle
Post-Intelligencer |
|
|